Cash-only budgets are popular among consumers who are trying to spend less. Instead of using credit cards and even debit cards, you pay for everything in cash. One of the most popular ways to do this is the envelope method, where you divide your cash into envelopes labeled for specific expenses.
While switching to a cash-only lifestyle is said to help with managing your finances, it also has some big disadvantages. If you've been thinking about giving it a try, here's what you can expect when paying for everything in cash.
You may spend less
The main argument for only using cash is that it could help you spend less money. Multiple studies have found that people are willing to spend more when paying with credit cards than with cash. That includes research by MIT, the American Psychological Association, and Dun & Bradstreet.
It's not guaranteed, and you can certainly stick to a budget while using credit cards. But the research shows that people find it easier to spend money with a credit card than to actually part with cold, hard cash. When we pay for purchases with cash, we're more aware of what we're spending.
You miss out on the opportunity to earn rewards
One of the benefits of paying by credit card is that you can earn rewards. There are plenty of rewards credit cards that earn 1% to 2% back, or sometimes more, on eligible purchases. And while rewards cards may seem complex, most of them are easy to use. If you want to keep it simple, any of the top cash back cards are good options. These let you apply your cash back as a statement credit on your credit card bill.
When you pay with cash, you don't get anything back. Over time, that adds up. Let's say that you spend $25,000 per year on purchases you could make with a credit card. If you use a card that earns 2% back, that will earn you $500 in cash back per year. That's $500 you won't get by paying with cash.
You need to carry more cash around
Something that doesn't always get brought up about cash-only budgets is how inconvenient they are. You need to keep enough cash on hand to cover all your bills. That likely means doing either of the following:
- Keep enough cash at home for the next month's expenses. This is how the envelope method works. You take the money you need from your envelopes as you need it.
- Make frequent visits to the ATM. If you do this, you'll need to watch out for ATM fees or stick to ATMs in your bank's network.
Paying with a credit or debit card is much easier, because you only need enough cash for emergencies. There's also far less risk involved. You can't get your cash back if your wallet is lost or stolen, but you can get a replacement credit card and be no worse off.
You aren't able to dispute transactions
An underrated benefit of credit and debit cards is the option to dispute transactions. If you're not satisfied with a purchase, and you can't work things out with the merchant, you can dispute it with your card issuer. Your card's payment network (Visa, Mastercard, American Express, or Discover) will then get information from you and the merchant to investigate. If it determines that you're in the right, you get a refund.
This is a helpful option to have if there are issues with a purchase you made. Sometimes just the threat of a dispute makes merchants more willing to work with you.
If you paid with cash, your options are much more limited. The merchant would need to agree to refund you, because it's not an electronic payment that can be reversed. Your only other option would be to go the legal route.
Because of the benefits they offer, credit cards are generally the best way to pay for purchases. If you often find yourself overspending, you may want to switch to cash. But in the long run, it's better to figure out how to spend responsibly while paying with credit cards.
Alert: our top-rated cash back card now has 0% intro APR until 2025
This credit card is not just good – it’s so exceptional that our experts use it personally. It features a lengthy 0% intro APR period, a cash back rate of up to 5%, and all somehow for no annual fee! Click here to read our full review for free and apply in just 2 minutes.
FAQs
Paying for everything with cash could help you spend less, because consumers are normally more willing to spend when using credit cards. You miss out on the chance to earn rewards, such as cash back or points.
Is it good to pay for everything in cash? ›
No Interest Charges
Using only cash has a big advantage, as Manktelow-Pimm pointed out: “When you use cash, you don't have to worry about interest charges on credit cards or loans. This can save you a lot of money in the long run.”
What happens when you only pay cash? ›
You Avoid Fees and Charges
While you may pay the same price for a product or service, whether you are paying cash or credit, with a cash only purchase, you won't have to pay the additional charges often associated with credit cards.
Can you live on cash only? ›
An exclusively cash lifestyle may help you follow your budget, sidestep overspending, and avoid the high cost of overdraft, interest, and other fees that can be incurred when you pay by check, debit, and/or credit card.
Why is it better to pay in cash? ›
More businesses are offering financial incentives to consumers who pay with cash rather than credit card. Consumers may save 2% to 4% on their purchase by using cash. They'll also often save with a debit card, experts said. Businesses charge more for credit card purchases due to fees they incur per transaction.
What are the disadvantages of paying with cash? ›
The disadvantages of cash:
- Hygiene concerns. Coins and banknotes exchange hands often. ...
- Risk of loss. Cash can be lost or stolen fairly easily. ...
- Less convenience. ...
- More complicated currency exchanges. ...
- Undeclared money and counterfeiting.
“Basically any electronic purchase should be done with a credit card,” she said. “Not only will you have some purchase protection by doing this, rather than paying with cash, but many credit cards offer extra warranties on top of what a product may come with or what a store will offer.”
What is the 3000 cash rule? ›
Funds Transfer and Travel Rule Requirements
Treasury regulation 31 CFR Section 103.33 prescribes information that must be obtained for funds transfers in the amount of $3,000 or more.
How much cash is too much to keep at home? ›
Jesse Cramer, associate relationship manager at Cobblestone Capital Advisors, believes less than $1,000 is ideal. “It [varies from] person to person, but an amount less than $1,000 is almost always preferred,” he said. “There simply isn't enough good reason to keep large amounts of liquid cash lying around the house.
Is it legal to hold all your money in cash? ›
Having large amounts of cash is not illegal, but it can easily lead to trouble. Law enforcement officers can seize the cash and try to keep it by filing a forfeiture action, claiming that the cash is proceeds of illegal activity. And criminal charges for the federal crime of “structuring” are becoming more common.
You Don't Want a Record of Your Transactions
Using a credit card or digital payment method to buy something means creating a record of that purchase. Consumers who are very concerned about privacy may opt to use cash to avoid leaving a trail of how and where they spend their money.
How much cash can I carry? ›
YOU ARE ALLOWED TO CARRY AS MUCH CASH AS YOU WANT OUT OF AND INTO THE UNITED STATES. To summarize up front: no, you are not restricted to traveling with sums of $10,000 or less. In fact, you could travel with a checked bag stuffed to the brim with cash — as long as you declare the amount beforehand.
Why is all cash better? ›
Less paperwork and bureaucracy: Cutting out the lender also means cutting out much of the paperwork and hassles associated with a traditionally financed sale. Less risky: Without financing or a lender-required appraisal contingency, an all-cash transaction is less likely to fall through — cash is more of a sure bet.
Is it good to keep all your money in cash? ›
It's a good idea to keep a small sum of cash at home in case of an emergency. However, the bulk of your savings is better off in a savings account because of the deposit protections and interest-earning opportunities that financial institutions offer.
Should I move everything to cash? ›
Key Takeaways. While holding or moving to cash might feel good mentally and help avoid short-term stock market volatility, it is unlikely to be wise over the long term. Once you cash out a stock that's dropped in price, you move from a paper loss to an actual loss.
Is it bad to keep large amounts of cash? ›
“It [varies from] person to person, but an amount less than $1,000 is almost always preferred,” he said. “There simply isn't enough good reason to keep large amounts of liquid cash lying around the house.
What is a good amount to keep in cash? ›
The recommended amount of cash to keep in savings for emergencies is three to six months' worth of living expenses. If you have funds you won't need within the next five years, you may want to consider moving it out of savings and investing it. How much money do experts recommend keeping in your checking account?
